Debs is magnificent in this denunciation of the pearl-clutching press, pulpit, and capitalist politician over Chicago’s crooked labor leaders when it was the system they defended that was entirely responsible for creating the position in the first place.
‘Chicago’s “Crooked” Labor Leaders’ by Eugene V. Debs from The Seattle Union Record. Vol. 5 No. 53. June 223, 1922.
The virtuous capitalists of Chicago are staging a grim and spectacular war against the “crooked labor leaders” of the Windy City. The attention of the entire country has been aroused by the hue and cry of the crusading capitalists and their press and politicians and pulpiteers, all howling in concert against the union leaders who have wrought such havoc with law and order and brought such disgrace upon the city. Let us take a brief survey of this alleged war by Chicago’s virtuous capitalist “citizens” against alleged labor crooks, look beneath the surface, and see where the crookedness really lies, and who is actually responsible for it. The beginning of the recent bombings and riotous outbreaks in Chicago dates from the notorious “arbitration” in the building trades put over by Judge Kenesaw Mountain (!) Landis, the capitalist lackey who in his award cut the throats of the workers as he had cut the throats of their leaders in his court of ill fame by putting them in penitentiary for 20 years for refusing to bow to his masters and betray their own followers.
Landis is the corporation lick-spittle, the lantern-jawed freak, the cheapest of all cheap bourgeois skates who got his notoriety by fining Rockefeller $29,000,000 when he knew that not a cent of it would ever be paid, and the workers in the building trades certainly committed an astonishing blunder and were victimized with a vengeance when this vulgar mountebank was chosen to arbitrate their grievances. From the moment that was done their case was lost. They had as well surrender from the start and meekly the accept whatever I crooked contractors might in their mercy see fit to allow them.
Now let it be admitted in all candor that Chicago has been infested, as other cities have, with crooked labor leaders.
But who is responsible for these false leaders and their crooked methods and contemptible betrayal? That is the question I propose to answer in this article and in doing so I shall address myself directly to the captains of industry, the industrial masters and their bosses and other tools and accessories.
Since when, let me ask you gentlemen, especially at Chicago, have you wanted honest instead of crooked labor leaders? You know in your hearts, such as they are, that you have no earthly use, and never have had, for an honest leader of the working class. The honest leader is above and beyond your foul clutches, your corrupting influence, your criminal methods, and you have not a moment’s time nor a bit of patience with him and you know it. And you know, too, some of you at least, that I have dealt with you face to face, that I have had personal experience with you, and that I know you of my own knowledge and at first hand. You not only have no use in your business for an honest labor leader, but you do not tolerate him at all if through your vicious and debauching influence he can be stripped of his office and driven from power, as is often the case, for the labor movement, like all other institutions under your exploiting and enslaving system, is infested with your lackeys and spies, bears your dirty finger prints, and suffers from your domination and control.
You first did all in your power to prevent your slaves from organizing at all. Failing in that and realizing that the labor movement was inevitable in the logic of events, you changed your tactics; your scowls softened to smiles, you began to coddle its leaders and called them your “lieutenants,” and from that time to this you have exhausted your ingenuity in converting the labor movement into your auxiliary that it might harmonize with your plans and serve your greed and rapacity in the exploitation of its members. To this end you have flattered the union leader, your agents have been cheek by jowl with him if he yielded to their blandishments, and you have corrupted him into the betrayal of his trust, the sacrifice of his honor and self-respect to the exact extent that you have controlled his actions to serve your predatory interests.
Have Not Corrupted All
You have not succeeded in corrupting all of labor’s leaders, but that is not your fault. You have done your best and worst in that direction.
You had not money enough to corrupt nor power enough to intimidate Martin Irons and your prostitute press covered him with obloquy and hounded him to an exile’s grave.
At Chicago you have notoriously produced and pampered the crooked labor leader; you have connived with him as your tool to destroy your rivals; you have used him to the limit in all your nefarious operations and now that he has learned the game in your school, become an adept under your tutelage, and is reacting with unerring logic to imitate his creator, you crooked capitalists, you criminal contractors, you conscienceless exploiters of labor and looters of the nation arise in your outraged Innocence, in your immaculate virtue as a “citizens’ committee” and cry out against your former pals, the “crooked labor leaders” whom you charge with having violated the public morality and precipitated an orgy of crime upon the city, and you demand their extermination, backed by a million dollar fund, the proceeds of your own spoilation and depravity. Oh, ye hypocrites, ye false pretenders, ye whited sepulchers filled with all corruption!
You are the last on earth to turn on the “crooked labor leader,” for you are his creator, his sponsor and without you he could never have been.
You put up every dollar, every penny ever used in your unholy Chicago “labor wars” and in the purchase and corruption of the “crooked leaders” you now hypocritically reprobate in the carnival of crime which has resulted from your own debauching machinations.
You have bought leaders trusted by the working class with political office and you have purchased them outright with the cold cash, but in every such transaction it was you, and you alone, who provided the means with which it was done and you are infinitely more responsible than your disgraced and discredited victims.
You have recently aroused the country by your cry for vengeance against the bomber, the thug, and the gunman, but it does not seem to have occurred to you that it is your own chickens that are coming home to roost.
Who but you established, endowed and maintained the school for the training of these degenerates, and who but you provided them with employment when they were awarded their diplomas in your colleges of crime?
A Few Classic Examples
Carnegie at Homestead, Pullman at Chicago, and latterly Gary in the empire of the steel trust are a few of the classic examples that may be scanned with interest and studied with profit by the silk-hatted gentry of the Windy City who are now in a frenzy of vindictive hate, purple with rage, a characteristic spasm of capitalist virtue, demanding the extermination of their own progeny, the bombist, the thug and the gunman from the face of the earth.
You are morally responsible for every crook that has ever betrayed and every thug that has ever disgraced the labor movement.
Take a look into West Virginia at this very hour and tell me what you think of yourself! I have been driven from there and from other states by your thugs and gunmen, your “mounted constabulary,” your “coal and iron police” and other hired assassins of whom you maintain a standing army to keep your slaves in subjection, and I know them well, even better than Elbert Gary himself. And I know beyond any question of doubt who brought them into being, who profits by their satanic services, and who is responsible at the bar of judgment for their infamous crimes. From Maine to California, from Minnesota to Louisiana, the gunmen, thugs and assassins, organized and maintained in detachments, squads and regiments, constituting the private army of the American capitalists, every mother’s son of them a “patriot” and “one hundred per cent American,” are on your pay-roll and under your orders to do the unspeakably dirty work required to maintain your eminent respectability in capitalist society, while Tom Mooney and Warren Billings, Nicola Sacco, Bartolomeo Vanzetti and hundreds of other honest labor leaders, men who would scorn to be crooked and betray their class, and whom the whole world knows to be innocent of crime, continue in spite of the protest of every decent citizen in the land, to rot in your pestilential prison pens.
The gall, the unmitigated gall you have in pretending to expose crooked labor leaders while either keeping the honest ones in penitentiary or raiding their quarters and threatening to send them there, is equaled only by your hypocritical cant about law and order, virtue and morality, while at the same time you are resorting to every artifice your perverted ingenuity can devise to satisfy your insatiable rapacity and greed.
When you capitalists and your mercenary hirelings condemn “crooked labor leaders,” it is only when, under your patronage and with your connivance, they have become your competitors for the spoils instead of your mere creatures in crime.
The Seattle Union Record was the paper of of that city’s Central Labor Council begun as a weekly in 1910. For most of its life the paper was edited by long-time Socialist activist Harry Ault, who had participated in the Washington State Socialist Party’s factional struggles before leaving in 1910. A progressive labor paper, the Union Record grew along with Seattle’s labor movement. Becoming a daily in 1918 it is best known as the record of Seattle’s 1919 General Strike when the print run reached 80,000 an edition in 1919. Continuing as the paper of the C.L.C. until 1924 when Ault purchased the paper, it ran until 1928.
PDF of full issue: https://washingtondigitalnewspapers.org/?a=d&d=SUR19220623
