With notable exceptions, before the GI Bill and the opening of large state systems after the Second World War, the world of college and university students was largely bourgeois and reactionary. A discussion article from a founder and, for years, leader of the Young Communist League and International, Martin Abern–here in the Communist League-Left Opposition–reflects on the Y.C.L.’s recent project of creating the National Student League, rejecting a separate body for student work, and the whole notion of ‘bridge’ organizations.
‘Shall the Revolutionary Students Be Organized into Separate Movements’ by Martin Abern from The Militant. Vol. 6 Nos. 5 & 6. February 4 & 11, 1933.
The existence for some time now of the National Students League in the United States, organized through the instrumentality of the Communist party and YCL, requires from the Left Opposition a fundamental statement of its attitude toward the NSL. Can the Communists stand by quietly when there is formed an independent students’ organization, with its own programmatic policy? Moreover, can Communists assist in, and be responsible for, the formation of such independent student organizations?
The recent activities of the NSL and its assumption of various roles in the class struggle bring this question sharply to the forefront and demand a clear enunciation of policy on our part. The organization recently of the Students League of Canada only adds to the need for clarification on the question. The writer presents his views here in sketched form in order to initiate a discussion which will speed the adoption of a position by the Left Opposition. Communists in principle, must oppose, in our opinion, the formation of an independent or separate organization of either the students or the intellectuals. This position, which has been the principle position of the Communists and the Young Communist International in theses adopted at the second congress of the Y.C.L., requires no revision today.
Role of Students
The students have no independent role to play in society and require no separate organization. The division of the students may be roughly made into rich, middle class or petit-bourgeois and proletarian students. Even so, the particular social, economic and political positions of these groupings in society negate any idea that these groups can have an independent role in the class struggle as student groups. Our concern here is mainly with the proletarian students who have historically no interests separate and apart from the industrial proletariat, from the working class as such The proletarian students to be at all effective in the labor movement, must link themselves organizationally and politically with the vanguard of the revolutionary movement – the Communist party and the YCL, and conduct such activities as they are able to on a Communist program. The Communist student would necessarily, therefore, direct his energies primarily among the proletarian students.
The matter becomes even clearer when it is seen that the National Students League and the Students League of Canada are not formed on the basis of a “broad” student organization which supposedly might appeal to all classes of students for the preservation of student rights and needs on the campus, or conduct “general propaganda” and education for liberal, socialist or revolutionary ideas. Both Student Leagues, on the contrary, recognize the weakness of such a position and make their appeal on a “revolutionary” or even “Communistic” basis. In fact, they regard themselves as Communist student organizations. The Spark, official organ of the Students League of Canada, is most clear and explicit on the matter of the character of its appeal to the student body. In the issue of December 1932, the Spark editorially says:
“… The majority of students … are not members of the proletariat, even though a good many come from working class homes. Because of this fact Marxism, however logical, can have no appeal to most university students for it is inimical to the interests of their class. Accordingly, the Students League has no illusions regarding the student body as a whole … We only aim to attract the small number of students who see an identity between their interests and those of the working class and who are, therefore, willing to take an active part in the working class movement. After all, a few active members are far more valuable than is a passive recognition of the validity of our views from the majority of the student body – and again on this latter score we have no illusions.” (Our emphasis)
What the Spark says is correct. But if there is this identity of interests between the students minority, that is, the proletarian students and the workers, then why a separate organization? What are those special tasks of so-called revolutionary or Communist student organizations which cannot better and more correctly be performed in the revolutionary political organisation of the youth – the Young Communist League? In our opinion, none; and such an independent student organization can only lead to confusion and malpractices in the revolutionary movement, and bring about just the opposite results from those intended, as will be shown.
The Communist Left Opposition particularly has every reason to reject the organization of separate students organizations. The Left Opposition, in its condemnation of the Stalinists, has stated often, and correctly, its opposition in principle to the creation of so-called “anti-imperialist” Leagues, “peasants” parties, “workers and peasants parties”, labor or Farmer-Labor parties, etc., etc. We condemn the formation of these bodies on the ground that they usurp, or attempt to, the role legitimately and necessarily belonging to the Communist party, and, further, that every concession to the formation and activity of such organizations brings successive betrayals of the working class, emasculates and caricatures the revolutionary position, and weakens or destroy the Communist party or YCL. In short, the theoretical position of the Left Opposition, based on historical experiences, refuses to attribute an independent or revolutionary role to such hodge-podge bodies. Our attitude toward the NSL and the Students League of Canada must flow clearly from our fundamental position to analogous organizations in other fields. In the case of an independent students organization, the issue is even plainer.
The Left Opposition contends that the role of a “peasants” party, an “anti-imperialist League”, a “four class Kuo Min Tang”, a Labor party, etc., proves in every case to be false to, a betrayal of, and reactionary in relation to the working class as a whole, and also, thereby, to the Communists and their organizations, the C.P. and YCL. In such cases, where “independent” organizations like the NSL pretend to a “revolutionary”, even Communist position, they place themselves directly in the road of the genuine revolutionization of the proletarian students who, if they accept the revolutionary, the Communist position, should join the organization of their class, the YCL, and function actively therein in their allotted tasks. Wittingly or otherwise, the “revolutionary” position of the NSL, sponsored and organized by the YCL, actually forms a bulwark against – and not a bridge to – students joining the YCL. Yet what is demanded of them in the way of profession of belief and activity in the NSL that is not demanded of them in the YCL – minus the discipline required of a member of the YCL? Little or nothing, under ordinary circumstances.
It is demonstrated, not merely in theory but by numerous practices, that when the students or intellectuals undertake tasks, in lieu of no objection by others, which are not theirs historically and which they cannot properly execute – they bungle the job badly, confuse and mislead the workers, ignore the revolutionary position and, by default, usurp the role which only a C.P. or YCL can undertake. They are not to blame, since no one says them nay, and, worse yet, the Communists themselves urge them on in their false steps.
If there is any instance where only the Communists can lead effectively and correctly, it is in the struggle against capitalist militarism and imperialist war. Yet, witness the spectacle at the Barbusse Congress at Amsterdam when the Communist International abandoned its rightful role of leadership to the intellectuals! Comment here is superfluous; the Militant has dealt fully with this Congress and at the Student Conference Against War at Chicago, initiated by the NSL and the Communists, the Amsterdam spectacle was repeated in an even more grotesque manner. The YCL abandoned its field and the results of the Chicago Conference were – confusion, disorganization, perversion and misrepresentation of the revolutionary ways and means to combat imperialist war except as clarified by delegates and supporters of the Communist Left Opposition. (See the articles on the Chicago Student Conference in the Militant by Aderhabe and A. Glotzer for an analysis of this Conference). It was inevitable there, as at Amsterdam or wherever the same stunt is tried, that when the intellectuals or students took over the leadership in the anti-militarist movement, the real basis of struggle against war was vitiated and the workers misled. The C. P. and YCL stood in the wings, behind the scenes, witnessing, approvingly, the spectacle and abandoned their leading role. Was the revolutionary student participating in such a conference doing his duty in attempting to lead this struggle against capitalist war? He thought so. But he was doomed to failure. Yet subordinate to, and a part of the YCL, the revolutionary students could take a part, howsoever small or large, in a united front movement against war on specific issues.
On other questions, the NSL has taken a position which on the one hand is correct and on the other, false. For instance, the “revolutionary” NSL endorsed the Communist party in the November elections: a correct action. But it motivated its support of the C.P., not on revolutionary class grounds, but on the fact that the C.P., of all political parties consulted, had alone taken a stand for the students on their specific problems of class fees, etc. How ridiculous for an organization presumably pivoting on a revolutionary axis! Why should any such confusion arise among revolutionary students? It shouldn’t; the confusion is unnecessary and springs largely from the concept of an independent student role and the belief that revolutionary students should put forth more “palatable” or “adaptable” reasons for their revolutionary conclusions. This is the manner in which liberals and opportunists justify their stupidities or betrayals.
Yet, and this is another decisive factor, the Young Communist League, measured by its theoretical and organisational basis, is or should be a sufficiently broad organization to include within it not only young workers, but also the revolutionary-inclined students. The Communist Youth organization does not demand that young workers or students who desire to join it, shall be full-fledged Communists when they make application. It requires, arid properly so, that those joining it shall be willing to learn to be Communists, in theory and through participation in the struggles of the workers. We speak here not of the caricature that the YCL in the United States, and elsewhere, has become, but of the foundation upon which the Young Communist International was erected and the manner the YCLs were expected actually to function. For such students who join the NSL today because of its revolutionary program, we have to say that their place is directly in the ranks of the Communist youth organization.
It is a totally false conception of bridge organizations and their functions to accept the formation of an independent students’ organization as a part of that schema. An ILD, which defends class war victims irrespective of their political or economic views, is one thing. An independent students’ body with a political program and functions is an altogether different matter. An ILD has an obviously legitimate function to perform. An independent students’ organization can, and already has done great harm to the immediate and historical interests of the workers. That which tends to and does usurp the role of a revolutionary political party or YCL becomes a perversion of Marxist theory on the role of a Communist party. When the Stalinists aid in the formation of such bodies as the National Student League, workers and peasants parties, Labor party, anti-imperialist Leagues, etc., etc., they only further undermine the theoretical foundations of Marxism, and particularly the role of the C.P. and YCL. The NSL, in our opinion, is but another version or application of Stalinist theory, and as in the other cases it results only in additional blows delivered against the revolutionary movement. The Barbusse Conference and the American replicas of it are the demonstrations of how these blows are dealt.
But while the Left Opposition, hence, must stand opposed to the formation of independent students’ organizations, and more so when they masquerade as “revolutionary” or “Communist”, this by no means excludes work among the students. In whatever students’ organizations exist, the Communist must build fractions, even as they do in trade unions and other mass organizations of the workers, and there seek to develop Communist influence and win the individual students to the revolutionary banner and organization. Even as anti-imperialist papers can be issued by the Communist without special anti-imperialist organizations, so can Communist student papers be issued to proclaim its cause for the workers and proletarian students.
Win Students on Communist Basis
Nor need there be any neglect of neutralizing or trying to win as allies to the proletarian cause the middle class or petty bourgeois students, in the same manner, relatively, as we seek to make allies of the poor and exploited farmers But while we recognize the need to win such groups to accept the leadership of the proletariat and the Communists in the struggles against the bourgeoisie, yet it is not for us to aid in the creation of organizations of the petty bourgeoisie of various descriptions. Bigger and more important tasks remain for the Communists. Wherever any organization exists, however, which contains workers and other elements upon whom we can exert influence, the Communists enter, build fractions and conduct their work accordingly. But certainly Communists can never think of relinquishing the role of leadership, politically or organizationally, to such elements; for they are historically unqualified to do so; they cannot serve, with their confused and false programs, the interests of the working class and the vast mass of exploited. Trotsky points out in connection with the building of the Red Army: “The petty bourgeois intelligentsia could give the army a considerable number of lower officers. as they had done under czarism, but they could not create a commanding corps in their own image, for they had no image of their own.” Likewise, by analogy, the Communists nowhere must concede leading historical roles to forces incapable of “creating a commanding corps.” Wherever Stalinism has permitted them – and, worse, justified it – there have resulted debacles: in China on a tremendous world stage; in Amsterdam (Barbusse Congress) on a lesser, but still important scale; and in Chicago (Youth War Conference) on an illusionary and comic scale.
In short, the Left Communists must come to the conclusion, in the writer’s opinion, for the liquidation of the National Student League and similar creations, and insist that the Communist party and YCL take over the duties and role that properly belongs to them.
The Militant was a weekly newspaper begun by supporters of the International Left Opposition recently expelled from the Communist Party in 1928 and published in New York City. Led by James P Cannon, Max Schacthman, Martin Abern, and others, the new organization called itself the Communist League of America (Opposition) and saw itself as an outside faction of both the Communist Party and the Comintern. After 1933, the group dropped ‘Opposition’ and advocated a new party and International. When the CLA fused with AJ Muste’s American Workers Party in late 1934, the paper became the New Militant as the organ of the newly formed Workers Party of the United States.
PDF of full issue: https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/newspape/themilitant/1933/feb-04-1933.pdf
PDF of full issue 2: https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/newspape/themilitant/1933/feb-11-1933.pdf
