Nelson interviews Goldman and Reitman on their experiences at the hands of the law and order mob during the hard-fought, deadly Free Speech fight waged by the I.W.W. and others in 1912.
‘Emma Goldman and Ben Reitman Tell of San Diego Experience’ by Caroline Nelson from Industrial Worker. Vol. 4 No. 11. June 6, 1912.
The most fearless woman in America today undoubtedly is Emma Goldman. She told me that her first “crime” was committed in Russia when she was only eight years old. It happened in her own home. Her folks were farmers and had a servant girl, who got herself into trouble and was promptly kicked out into the cold world without any means. Emma forthwith robbed her mother’s strong-box and handed the proceeds to the outcast. I am not an anarchist because I can’t subscribe to their philosophy, but I can admire-a little woman who fought for years all alone for what is to her most sacred, and who went calmly on to fight in the teeth of all opposition. A dozen women of the Emma Goldman type in the labor movement could give the movement a boost that would make it leap ahead with lightning speed. Unfortunately for our working men today the working women are not revolutionary and mostly have the absurd idea that by construing the workers’ philosophy to mean nothing but a little reform they can do a whole lot of good. The socialist women in general are nothing short of a lot of geese, that confine themselves to cackling about uplifting the workers, and sprawl before upper-class or professional woman who will condescend to grace their meeting to hand them out a little respectability. Not so Emma Goldman, she stands by her guns through thick and thin, and goes with the police to jail with the same defiance that she mounts the platform to speak to a hostile audience, if need be.
She says that she went to San Diego in the midst of the free speech fight to compel the capitalistic press of the country to take notice of it which she knew it would be compelled to do, not because she is respectable, but because she is the most disreputable woman in America. Her object was certainly accomplished. In her own way of telling it, the listener is brought face to face with the fact that our civilization has hoisted into power the most savage and brutal members in society, who drop their veneer of culture at the least provocation. Miss Goldman said in part on her experiences in San Diego:
“I have seen mobs many times, but I have never seen such a yelling mob of thousands of well-dressed people as the one which greeted us at the depot in San Diego. We had engaged rooms at the U.S. Grant Hotel and we managed to get on the automobile hotel buss. Six private automobiles followed. They were filled with upper class women who hooted and yelled: “Give up that anarchist; we will strip her naked; we will tear out her guts!” Many other things were said by those “cultured” women which could not be repeated in public. The working men having charge of the hotel automobile raced for their life to save us from the vigilantes, which closed in on us at every turn. At last we got to the hotel to our rooms. The mob was held at bay by the hotel manager outside. But after a while they stormed the hotel and demanded that we be delivered over to them. The manager told them that it was his custom to protect his guests. They then told him that they would ruin him and tear down the building to get us. Finally a hotel clerk came to us and said that the chief of police wanted to see us. We told him to send the police to our rooms, but he said that we must come down and see him in a private room. We went with the clerk, and was taken by myself to a room where the chief of police, Wilson, and a man that looked like a detective were awaiting me. “We want you to sign a document demanding the protection of the police,” said Wilson. ‘I shall do no such a thing,’ I said. ‘The mob is beyond our control,’ said Wilson.’ ‘If the mob is beyond your control,’ said I ‘you are not fitted for your office and had better resign. Let me speak to the mob. I have soothed more than one mob.’ But the chief of police refused to allow me to speak to the mob and the interview ended.
“When I returned to our rooms I found that Ben Reitman had been kidnaped by the vigilantes. I then returned to the chief of police and declared that I should hold him personally responsible for Reitman’s life; that if any harm came to him he would have to pay for it, that I would come back to San Diego to take his life myself. Whereupon the official began to shake in his knees and declared that he had nothing to do with the kidnaping of Reitman.
“The manager again came to my room and said that he could not protect me from the mob, and asked me to leave the hotel, that I had no right to stay there and ruin him, as he had not asked me to come. I decided to leave on the next train for Los Angeles. The mob outside the hotel again followed me up in their automobiles. I reached the train and just as I stepped on the ground the vigilantes closed in on me and were on the point of grabbing me when the trainmen rescued a me and lifted me on board the train and slammed the car door in the face of the howling mob.”
Ben Reitman’s story is almost unbelievable. He says: “The moment Miss Goldman was out of the way a half dozen men clutched hold of me. One put his hand over my mouth. They threw me in a waiting automobile in the bottom and began to torture me and hysterically calling me by the vilest names. One of the men urinated on me, while others held met down. They took me twenty miles out in the desert where they stopped and threw me out. Immediately they tore off my clothes and threw me on the ground and with tar taken from a can traced I.W.W. on my back and a doctor, burned the letters in with a lighted cigar. I was then allowed to put on my underclothes because the Christian gentlemen feared that I might meet some ladies and shock them. I was also allowed to put on my vest. Then I was made to run the gauntlet of fourteen of these ruffians, who told me that they were not working men, but doctors, lawyers, real estate and business men. They tortured me and humiliated me in the most unspeakable manner. One of them was to put my cane in my rectum. Three hundred I.W.W.’s had gone through a similar torture before me by these Christian gentlemen.”
Emma Goldman declared that she had seen many mobs, but that in no instance had the mobs been made up of working people, but always of the respectable citizens.
Anyhow the whole state of California is stirred up over this San Diego free speech fight. Spreckles Call in San Francisco and his papers in San Diego have done all they could to stir this mess into a patriotic stew, but the whole working class of every brand of organization is on to the game, and knows it is a class struggle. This fight is the greatest thing that ever happened in California to promote class consciousness. Everybody is asking what is the I.W.W. Let the good fight go on. All we need is to capture the workers’ mind, when we have that we have all. And one of the best ways to capture it, is to make the capitalist press advertise what we stand for. All activities lead to revolution. Peace and submission is our greatest enemy at this stage of the game.
The Industrial Union Bulletin, and the Industrial Worker were newspapers published by the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) from 1907 until 1913. First printed in Joliet, Illinois, IUB incorporated The Voice of Labor, the newspaper of the American Labor Union which had joined the IWW, and another IWW affiliate, International Metal Worker.The Trautmann-DeLeon faction issued its weekly from March 1907. Soon after, De Leon would be expelled and Trautmann would continue IUB until March 1909. It was edited by A. S. Edwards. 1909, production moved to Spokane, Washington and became The Industrial Worker, “the voice of revolutionary industrial unionism.”
PDF of full issue: https://www.marxists.org/history/usa/pubs/industrialworker/iw/v4n11-w167-jun-06-1912-IW.pdf
